Referendum 'Stuttgart 21'

Project Directors Prof. Dr. Thorsten Faas, Prof. Dr. Rüdiger Schmitt-Beck Project Staff Johannes N. Blumenberg, M.A. Julia Range Ministry of the Prime Minister of the State of Baden-Württem-funded 2011 – 2016

Research question/goal:

In 2011, the public conflict over the infrastructure project 'Stuttgart 21' reached its climax, raising fundamental questions concerning the modes of political participation and the legitimacy of political decisions. It became clear that the participation processes that had been part of the planning and approval stage were not enough to ensure the general acceptance of the project. Even after the referendum in November 2011, the debate about 'Stuttgart 21' and the democratic quality of governance in the federal state of Baden-Württemberg didn’t subside; this is hardly surprising, as participation in general (and 'Stuttgart21' in particular) was an important part of the political agenda of the green-red government. In this study, we focused on the long-term trends in acceptance, evaluation, and interest accompanying 'Stuttgart 21' and the referendum that was held in November 2011. Additionally, we examined the attitudes of citizens towards democracy and political participation in Baden-Württemberg for the entire period of the green-red government until fall 2015.

In terms of its research design, the project was designed as a follow-up to the rolling panel project “Election Study Baden-Württemberg 2011”: respondents were invited to participate in three additional waves in the immediate context of the referendum in November 2011. Furthermore, yearly waves were added in 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2015 to track public opinion over time. Finally, six representative cross-sectional telephone surveys were included. Overall, the applied methods and collected data allowed us to trace and analyse in great detail processes of opinion formation and decision-making in a case study of direct democracy, namely in the immediate context of the referendum, but also over time. Results were (and still are) presented at academic conferences as well as meetings at different levels in the political arena in Baden-Württemberg.


Publications

Book Chapters

  • EU-LAC Foundation, (Eds.) Faas, Thorsten (2015): Democratic Responsiveness in the Stuttgart21 Process: Arbitration, Referendum and a Dialogue. 143-161. Hamburg, EU-LAC Foundation. More
  • Wagschal, Uwe, Ulrich Eith, Michael Wehner (Eds.) Blumenberg, Johannes N., Thorsten Faas (2013): Stuttgart 21: Einstellungen und Emotionen. 1, 229-246. Baden-Baden, Nomos. More
  • Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung, , Elisabeth Kinderlen, Helga Metzner (Eds.) Faas, Thorsten (2013): Im Südwesten nichts Neues? Von wegen! Zwei Jahre Baden-Württemberg im Lichte von Bevölkerungsumfragen. 32, 22-35. Berlin, Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung. More

Journal Articles

  • Faas, Thorsten, Johannes N. Blumenberg (2012): Die Vermessung der Dynamik: Eine rollierende Panelstudie im Vorfeld der baden-württembergischen Lantagswahl 2011. Methoden, Daten, Analysen : mda ; Zeitschrift für empirische Sozialforschung, 6, 2, 157-183. More
  • Blumenberg, Johannes N., Thorsten Faas (2012): Abstimmung gut, alles gut?. Der Bürger im Staat, 3, 182-187. More

Presentations

  • Faas, Thorsten, Julia Range (2015): Bürgerbeteiligung und wissenschaftliche Evaluation. [Fachtagung "Politik mit Bürgern - Politik für Bürger: Praxis und Perspektiven einer neuen Beteiligungskultur", Staatskanzlei Rheinland-Pfalz, Mainz, 24/06/2015 - 24/06/2015]. More
  • Eder, Christina, Thorsten Faas (2015): Gegen den Bahnhof = für grün-rot? Eine Analyse des Abstimmungsverhaltens beim Volksentscheid zu Stuttgart 21 in Baden-Württemberg 2011. [Jahrestagung des DVPW-Arbeitskreises "Wahlen und politische Einstellungen", Heinrich-Heine-Universität, Düsseldorf, 10/06/2015 - 11/06/2015]. More
  • Faas, Thorsten (2013): Welche Beteiligung will "das Volk"? Zustimmung und Konfliktpotentiale. [Werkstattgespräch "Demokratieformen in den Ländern - Stand und Perspektiven", Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung, Hannover, 14/02/2013 - 14/02/2013]. More
  • Faas, Thorsten, Johannes N. Blumenberg (2013): Capturing Campaign Dynamics 2.0: A Rolling Panel Study in the Run-Up to the Baden-Wuerttemberg State Election 2011. [71st Annual Conference of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago, Il., 10/04/2013 - 13/04/2013]. More
  • Faas, Thorsten (2013): Campaign Communication in Comparison. [New Directions in Referendums: Politics and Campaigns, National University of Ireland, Dublin, 08/05/2013 - 08/05/2013]. More
  • Faas, Thorsten (2013): State Elections in Light of Fukushima and the Affective-Intelligence Model: The German Case of Baden-Württemberg. [71st Annual Conference of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago, IL , 10/04/2013 - 13/04/2013]. More
  • Blumenberg, Johannes N. (2012): Party Identification - Old but Gold!. [XXIInd World Congress of Political Science der International Political Science Association, Madrid, 07/07/2012 - 11/07/2012]. More
  • Faas, Thorsten (2012): Mehr Demokratie = Weniger Gleichheit?. [Fachveranstaltung "Einmischen erwünscht", Landeszentrale für politische Bildung Rheinland-Pfalz, Mainz, 04/09/2012 - 04/09/2012]. More
  • Faas, Thorsten (2012): Politische Kommunikation im Vorfeld des Volksentscheids zu Stuttgart 21. [Demokratiekonferenz 2012, Aarau, 20/06/2012 - 21/06/2012]. More
  • Faas, Thorsten, Johannes N. Blumenberg (2012): Scrutinizing Dynamics - Rolling Panel Waves in Theory and Practice. [General Online Research, DHBW, Mannheim, 04/03/2012 - 06/03/2012]. More