Personal Campaign Strategies and Political Representation

Project Directors Prof. Dr. Dr. h.c. Hermann Schmitt, Prof. Ph.D. Thomas Gschwend, Prof. Dr. Wolfgang C. Müller, Dr. Andreas M. Wüst, Prof. Dr. Thomas Zittel, Bernhard Weßels University of Mannheim, DFG, Fritz Thyssen Foundation-funded 2005 – 2018

Research question/goal:

The ongoing changes in the functioning of political parties stress individual representatives as alternative linkages between citizens and the state. This project studied the election campaigns of individual party candidates regarding a number of problems that have become relevant in this respect. It has put a special emphasis on campaign styles and on the following research questions: How can we systematically describe individualized election campaigns? How do they differ from party-driven campaigns? To what degree are we able to observe individualized campaigns in European elections? Which factors foster, which hinder the diffusion of individualized election campaigns? Based on two waves of the Comparative Candidates Survey (CCS) questionnaire, surveys of individual candidates standing for office in national parliamentary elections were administered across Europe; a third wave has been in the field since 2018. These surveys are questioning parliamentary candidates of political parties who operate under very different incentive structures in order to investigate whether and how these mattered to their campaigns.

A comparative data set including some 50 candidate surveys, conducted with the first wave questionnaire of the CCS, has been published in the Swiss data archive FORS. Furthermore, a preliminary version of the integrated data from the second wave is available. A number of journal articles and conference presentations have been published, and a comparative book project on wave one surveys has been proposed to Routledge. The three editors of that book—Lieven de Winter (Louvain and Brussels), Rune Karlson (Oslo) and Hermann Schmitt (Manchester and Mannheim)—have received a number of very favourable reviews for that book proposal and are looking forward to sign a book contract by the end of 2018.

Given the wealth of empirical evidence that has been assembled in the lifetime of the project and given the multitude of researchers in Germany and far beyond who analysed these data, the main findings are not easily summarised. What seems to be clear after more than a decade of empirical research into personalised campaigning is that European political parties remain to be the main agents of political representation. While personalisation of electoral campaigning does exist, there is no conclusive evidence that individual representatives have indeed replaced political parties as intermediaries, linking citizens and the state.


Publications

Book Chapters

  • Weßels, Bernhard, Harald Schoen, Oscar W. Gabriel (Eds.) Schmitt, Hermann (2013): Nationale Parteien oder lokale Kandidaten? Eine Analyse ihrer elektoralen Orientierungsleistung bei der Bundestagswahl 2009. 514-529. Wiesbaden, Springer VS. More
  • Gschwend, Thomas, Thomas Zittel, Rüdiger Schmitt-Beck (2011): Machen Wahlkreiskandidaten einen Unterschied? Die Persönlichkeitswahl als interaktiver Prozess. 45, 371-392. Baden-Baden, Nomos. More
  • Kittel, Bernhard, Wolfgang J. Luhan, Rebecca B. Morton (Eds.) Meffert, Michael F., Thomas Gschwend (2011): Experimental Triangulation of Coalition Signals: Varying Designs, Converging Results. 249-283. Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan. More
  • Gabriel, Oscar W., Bernhard Weßels, Jürgen W. Falter (Eds.) Wüst, Andreas M. (2009): Zur Sozialisation von Neuparlamentariern im 15. Deutschen Bundestag. 328-345. Wiesbaden, VS-Verlag. More
  • Rhodes, Rod A.W., Sarah Binder, Bert Rockman (Eds.) Zittel, Thomas (2006): Comparative Legislative Behavior. 455–473. Oxford, Oxford University Press. More

Journal Articles

  • Wüst, Andreas M. (2009): Bundestagskandidaten und Einwanderungspolitik: Eine Analyse zentraler Policy-Aspekte. Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft, 19, 1, 77-105. More
  • Zittel, Thomas, Thomas Gschwend (2008): Individualised Constituency Campaigns in Mixed-Member Electoral Systems: Candidates in the 2005 German Elections. West European Politics, 31, 5, 879-1003. More
  • Zittel, Thomas, Thomas Gschwend (2007): Individualisierte Wahlkämpfe im Wahlkreis. Eine Analyse am Beispiel des Bundestagswahlkampfes von 2005. Politische Vierteljahresschrift, 48, 2, 293-321. More
  • Wüst, Andreas M., Hermann Schmitt, Thomas Gschwend, Thomas Zittel (2006): Candidates in the 2005 Bundestag Election: Mode of Candidacy, Campaigning and Issues. German Politics, 15, 4, 420-438. More
  • Wüst, Andreas M. (2006): Wahlverhalten und politische Repräsentation von Migranten. Der Bürger im Staat, 56, 4, 228-234. More
  • Zittel, Thomas (2005): Die amerikanische Präsidentschaftswahl von 2004: Szenen eines Kulturkampfes. Geographische Rundschau, 57, 1, 59-64. More

Presentations

  • Gschwend, Thomas, Thomas Zittel (2015): Who brings home the pork? The role of electoral context and localness in assigning committee seats in the German Bundestag. [111th Annual Conference of the American Political Science Association, San Francisco, CA, 02/09/2015 - 05/09/2015]. More
  • Schmitt, Hermann (2013): Parties, Candidates and Voters in the 2009 Election of the European Parliament. [Vortragsreihe "Perspektiven der Forschung", LMU/Geschwister-Scholl-Institut, München, 22/01/2013 - 22/01/2013]. More
  • Wüst, Andreas M. (2011): Party and Group Representation? Issue positions and responsiveness of parliamentary candidates in Germany, Switzerland and Austria. [Dreiländertagung "Politische Integration", Basel, 12/01/2011 - 13/01/2011]. More
  • Zittel, Thomas (2009): Legislators and their Representational Roles. Rational Calculus or Habits of the Heart? and Local Campaigns in the German 2005 Elections: Motivations, Structures and Effects. [2009 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association (APSA), Toronto, 02/09/2009 - 05/09/2009]. More
  • Müller, Wolfgang C., Nikolaus Eder, Marcelo Jenny (2009): Party Democracy and Individualized Constituency Campaigning: Candidate Strategies and Behavior in the 2006 Austrian Elections. [Conference: Candidates in Constituency Campaigns from a Comparative Perspective. Is Collectivist Representation in Established Party Democracy under Stress?, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, 01/10/2009 - 02/10/2009]. More
  • Wüst, Andreas M. (2008): Candidate Nomination in Germany and Europe: Patterns and Evaluation. [Primaries or Nominating Committees? The Crisis of Nominations in Israeli Political Parties, Netanya, 15/11/2008 - 15/11/2008]. More
  • Wüst, Andreas M., Thomas Gschwend (2007): Die Bedeutung von Umfragen im Wahlkampf. [Moderne Politikvermittlung - Neue Wahlkampfformen in der Demokratie, Berlin, 03/05/2007 - 03/05/2007]. More
  • Wüst, Andreas M. (2007): Die deutschen Parteien, ihre Kandidaten und der Wählermarkt. [Zwischen Wählermarkt und Werteorientierung: Parteien und Programme im Wandel der Zeit, Wildbad Kreuth, 13/06/2007 - 14/06/2007]. More
  • Wüst, Andreas M. (2007): Bundestagskandidaten und Einwanderungspolitik: Eine Analyse zentraler Policy-Aspekte. [Jahrestagung des AK Wahlen und politische Einstellungen der DVPW, Main, 11/07/2007 - 11/07/2007]. More
  • Gschwend, Thomas, Thomas Zittel (2007): Individualisierte Wahlkämpfe im Wahlkreis: Eine Analyse am Beispiel des Bundestagswahlkampfes von 2005. [Wahlen und Repräsentation im politischen System der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Köln, 25/03/2007 - 25/03/2007]. More
  • Gschwend, Thomas (2006): Are Modern Politics still Party Politics?. [Inaugural Conference of the Comparative Candidates Study (CCS), Bad Dürkheim, 05/10/2006 - 07/10/2006]. More
  • Gschwend, Thomas, Henk van der Kolk (2006): Forecasting the Number of Split-Ticket Voters in Parliamentary Systems. [Conference of the Center for American Political Studies, Harvard University, on “Democracy, Divided Government, and Split-Ticket Voting”, Harvard, 25/05/2006 - 26/05/2006]. More
  • Zittel, Thomas, Thomas Gschwend (2006): Der Bundestagswahlkampf von 2005 und Kollektive Repräsentation: Ein kurzer Auftakt zum langen Abschied. [Gemeinsame Tagung der DVPW-Arbeitskreise "Politik und Kommunikation", "Wahlen und Einstellungen" und "Parteienforschung", Berlin, 18/07/2006 - 19/07/2006]. More
  • Zittel, Thomas, Thomas Gschwend (2006): Personalisierte Wahlkämpfe im Wahlkreis. Eine Analyse des Bundestagswahlkampfes von 2005. [3-Länder-Tagung "Politik und Persönlichkeit" der ÖGPW - SVPW - DVPW, Vienna, 29/11/2006 - 01/12/2006]. More