Party Competition and Policy Outcomes in Multilevel Systems

Project Directors Prof. Dr. Marc Debus, Prof. Dr. Jochen Müller EU-funded 2011 – 2021

Research question/goal:

The aim of the project was to first study the programmatic profile of political parties competing for votes at the regional level of European political systems. In a second step, the data was used to explain decision-making processes in the political process. This data included the determinants of the programmatic profile of parties at the regional level as well as the patterns of government formation, especially in the context of European integration and European regional funding. The starting point for this project was the growing importance of regions in modern democracies, which is evident in numerous studies on globalization and the advancing European integration process.

On the basis of theoretical models that take into account the institutional characteristics of the political systems and assume a political–economic, social–structural perspective, we derived expectations on the decision-making process of regional political parties in the European multilevel system. These expectations were empirically tested using newly created data sets, building on a body of preliminary work to measure the policy positions of parties and coalition governments at the national and the regional level. The multilevel systems examined comprised Western and Eastern European countries, whose sub-national units have different degrees of authority to influence the political process and policy outputs. Specifically, we collected the election manifestos and coalition agreements at the regional level for Austria, Belgium, Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy, the Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland, Spain, and the Czech Republic over a longer time. These were subsequently analysed with computerised methods of content analysis.

The analysis showed that parties at the regional level include the specific characteristics of the regional electorate when formulating their election manifestos. Furthermore, the positions that the regional parties take in their election manifestos play a crucial role in the process of government formation. In addition, the more the regions under study have received funding from the EU and its regional development programmes, the more likely they are to take a positive stance on European integration in their manifestos. With these findings, we closed a gap in the comparative analysis of governance in multilevel systems and thus in the subnational units. Moreover, due to the creation of data sets that provide information on the policy area–specific preferences of regional parties, we provide important empirical material for further research projects interested in the political and economic development of European regions. The full texts of the election manifestos of regional parties as well as the generated data sets are freely available at www.polidoc.net.


Publications

Book Chapters

  • Decker, Frank, Eckhard Jesse (Eds.) Debus, Marc, Jochen Müller (2013): Lohnt sich der Sprung über den Lagergraben? Existenz und Effekte politischer Lager im bundesdeutschen Parteienwettbewerb. 4, 259-278. Baden-Baden, Nomos. More

Journal Articles

  • Gross, Martin, Jochen Müller, Christian Stecker, Marc Debus (2025): Navigating complexity: exploring the changing dynamics of coalition avoidance in Germany, 1946-2023. Regional and Federal Studies, 35, 1, 51-73. More
  • Debus, Marc, Rosa M. Navarrete (2020): Do regional party primaries affect the ideological cohesion of political parties in multi-level systems? Evidence from Spain. Party Politics, 26, 6, 770-782. More
  • Debus, Marc, Thorsten Faas (2019): Die hessische Landtagswahl vom 28. Oktober 2018: Fortsetzung der schwarz-grünen Wunschehe mit starken Grünen und schwacher CDU. Zeitschrift für Parlamentsfragen, 50, 2, 245-262. More
  • Gross, Martin, Tim Niendorf (2017): Determinanten der Bildung nicht-etablierter Koalitionen in den deutschen Bundesländern, 1990 – 2016. Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft, 11, 3, 365-390. More
  • Bäck, Hanna, Marc Debus, Heike Klüver (2016): Bicameralism, Intra-party Bargaining, and the Formation of Party Policy Positions: Evidence from the German Federal System. Party Politics, 22, 3, 405-417. More
  • Klingelhöfer, Tristan, Jochen Müller (2015): Consociational and rational coalitions: Norm-based government formation and the case of the Dutch provinces. Acta Politica, 50, 1, 101-124. More
  • Tosun, Jale, Andreas Fleig, Marc Debus (2015): Bürger, Parteien und die Energiewende: Eine Analyse am Beispiel des hessischen Energiegipfels. Der moderne Staat: dms; Zeitschrift für Public Policy, Recht und Management, 8, 1, 153-171. More
  • Müller, Jochen, Marc Debus (2012): „Second order“-Effekte und Determinanten der individuellen Wahlentscheidung bei Landtagswahlen: Eine Analyse des Wahlverhaltens im deutschen Mehrebenensystem. Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft, 6, 1, 17-47. More

Presentations

  • Debus, Marc, David Schweizer (2023): The differentiated impact of perceived EU regional policy on citizens’ position on European integration. [29th International Conference of Europeanists, Reykjavik, 26/06/2023 - 28/06/2023]. More
  • Debus, Marc (2021): Parteienwettbewerb und Koalitionsbildung in Baden-Württemberg im Rahmen der Landtagswahl 2021. [Kiwi im Südwesten – Eine Bilanz der zweiten Regierung Kretschmann 2016-2021, (virtual workshop), 16/03/2021 - 17/03/2021]. More
  • Debus, Marc (2021): Parteien. Populismus. Pandemie. Protestwahl? Das baden-württembergische Parteiensystem vor der Landtagswahl. [Wahl-Web-Talk der Landeszentrale für politische Bildung Baden-Württemberg, (virtual), 26/01/2021 - 26/01/2021]. More
  • Debus, Marc (2021): Person, Partei, Programm - was die Wahl entscheidet. [POLITISCH BILDET – Landtagswahl 2021 spezial. Podcast der Landeszentrale für politische Bildung , (virtuell), 03/02/2021 - 03/02/2021]. More
  • Gross, Martin (2017): Does anyone care? Explaining the variation in sub-national parties’ emphasis of European issues and EU Cohesion policy. [1st Regional Research and Networking Conference, Heidelberg, 26/01/2017 - 26/01/2017]. More
  • Klingelhöfer, Tristan, Jochen Müller, Marc Debus (2014): Scrutinizing the Assumption of Consistency Benefits in Research on Multi-Level Party Politics.. [21st International Conference of Europeanists, Washington D.C., 13/03/2014 - 15/03/2014]. More
  • Debus, Marc, Heiner Stuckenschmidt, Hartmut Wessler (2014): On the Use of Different Modalities in Political Communication: Evidence from German Election Manifestos. [First Bremen Conference on Multimodality "Bridging the Gap between Here and There: Combining Multimodal Analysis from International Perspectives", University of Bremen, 09/09/2014 - 12/09/2014]. More
  • Obert, Peter, Jochen Müller (2013): The thresholds of representation and relevance and their implications for the survival of new parties in the context of Czech regional elections. [ECPR General Conference, Sciences Po, Bordeaux, 03/09/2013 - 06/09/2013]. More
  • Debus, Marc, Jochen Müller (2012): Gibt es politische Lager? Lohnt sich der Sprung über den Lagergraben? Eine Analyse auf Grundlage der programmatischen Positionen der deutschen Landesparteien von 1990 bis 2011. [Tagung "Die deutsche Koalitionsdemokratie vor der Bundestagswahl 2013", Tutzing, 12/01/2012 - 14/01/2012]. More

Reports

  • Heichel, Stephan, Martin Gross, Marc Debus (2018): Cohesion policy implementation, performance and communication: Baden-Württemberg case study. 82. More
  • Debus, Marc, Martin Gross (2017): Positions on and issue emphasis of European integration and EU Cohesion policy: Analysing (sub-)national party manifestos. 4, 57. More