Parliaments, Representative Government and New Electronic Media Environments: An International Comparison

Project Directors Prof. Dr. Thomas Zittel Fritz-Thyssen-Stiftung; Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft-funded 2000 – 2006

Research question/goal:

New digital media such as the World Wide Web (WWW) open up new opportunities for constituency communication with possible ramifications for the responsiveness of representative democracy. This project studies from a comparative perspective, whether and how MPs are using these new opportunities and what interests and perceptions they attach to these new tools. The data for this research are based upon close to 100 semi-structured interviews with MPs in three parliaments and upon a content analysis of all personal websites in three parliaments conducted at two points in time (4/2000 und 4/2004).
The project was guided by a theoretical assumption that perceives the use of the WWW for constituency communication as the result of the interplay between new opportunities to communicate on the one hand and institutional incentives on the other, and as the consequence of particular causal mechanisms that link the makro and mikro level of analysis. I firstly assumed that the new opportunities to communicate would affect constituency communication through processes of social change in direct (e.g. generational change in parliament) as well as indirect ways (e.g. generational change among the voters; high internet penetration in district). I secondly assumed that different types of voting systems and different types of government would provide incentives for personalized communication that vary in degree and that would influence the usage of new media for constituency communication. These theoretical assumptions were tested in this project with the three following core findings.
Parliaments are firstly under stress due to new opportunities for constituency communication. Personal websites are used in all three parliaments particularly among young MPs representing highly educated and well-off districts with high internet penetration. The weight of each of these causal mechanisms differs across parliaments. Incentives for personalized communication explain secondly different levels and forms of usage in the three parliaments under study. A third finding demonstrates, that the usage of the WWW for constituency communication can not be explained by single institutional factors but that it is dependent in its particular pattern by a particular institutional configuration. While the voting system has a significant impact on usage in the US House and the German Bundestag, it has close to no impact in the case of the Swedish Riksdag due to specific contextual factors.


Publications

Edited Books

  • Kaiser, André, Thomas Zittel (Eds.) (2004): Demokratieentwicklung und Demokratietheorie. Festschrift für Peter Graf Kielmansegg. 470. Wiesbaden, VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften. More

Book Chapters

  • Zittel, Thomas (2005): What can the Vep model do for democracy? ... in answer to Alexander Trechsel. 51-56. Strasbourg, Council of Europe. More
  • Esser, Frank, Barbara Pfetsch (Eds.) Zittel, Thomas (2004): Political Communication and Electronic Democracy. American Exceptionalism or Global Trend?. 231 - 250. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. More
  • Schmitt, Karl (Eds.) Zittel, Thomas (2003): Elektronische Demokratie - ein alternatives Modell zur liberalen Demokratie?. 175 - 193. Baden-Baden, Nomos. More
  • Pfetsch, Barbara, Frank Esser (Eds.) Zittel, Thomas (2003): Vernetzte politische Kommunikation: Elektronische Demokratie als amerikanischer Sonderweg?. 259-280. Opladen, Westdeutscher Verlag. More

Journal Articles

  • Zittel, Thomas (2003): Political Representation in the Networked Society: The Americanisation of European Systems of Responsible Party Government?. Journal of Legislative Studies, 9, 3, 32-53. More
  • Zittel, Thomas (2001): Elektronische Demokratie - Planskizze für eine Demokratie des 21.Jahrhunderts?. Neue Politische Literatur, 3, 433-470. More

Presentations

  • Zittel, Thomas (2005): Researching Electronic Democracy: Embedded Webanalysis. [Workshop zu Methoden der E-Demokratie Forschung, EUI, Florence, 27/04/2005 - 28/04/2005]. More
  • Zittel, Thomas (2005): Personalisierte Wählerkommunikation im Deutschen Bundestag. [Fachgespräch im Deutschen Bundestag zum Thema Elektronische Parlamente auf Einladung der Vizepräsidentin des Deutschen Bundestages Dr. Susanne Kastner, Berlin, 13/02/2005 - 13/02/2005]. More
  • Zittel, Thomas (2005): Participatory Engineering: Can Democratic Reform increase Political Participation?. [Annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Washington, DC, 30/08/2005 - 03/09/2005]. More
  • Zittel, Thomas (2004): MPs and the Internet - Between the Rock of Technology and the Hard Place of Politics. [Siebte Konferenz der Arbeitsgemeinschaft der Europäischen Parlamente zu Themen der Informations- und Kommunikationstechnologie, Stockholm, 26/10/2004 - 28/10/2004]. More
  • Zittel, Thomas (2004): What can ICTs do for Democracy?. [Council of Europe Conference: The Future of Democracy, Centro de Convenciones International de Barcelona, Barcelona, 16/11/2004 - 18/11/2004]. More
  • Zittel, Thomas (2004): American Democracy: A Model for European Integration?. [ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshops, Workshop Nr. 12: National Traditions of Democratic Theory (Directors: Heidrun Abromeit und Andreas Follesdal)., Universität Uppsala, Uppsala, 12/04/2004 - 17/04/2004]. More
  • Zittel, Thomas (2004): MPs and the Internet: Between the Rock of Technology and the Hard Place of Politics. [Seventh European Conference of Members of National Parliaments on Information and Communications Technologies., Schwedischer Riksdag, Stockholm, 26/09/2004 - 28/09/2004]. More

Reports

  • Zittel, Thomas (2005): Direkte Personalisierte Wählerkommunikation im WWW - Wunsch, Wirklichkeit und Perspektiven. Gutachten im Auftrag des Deutschen Bundestages. Vorgelegt dem Büro für Technikfolgen-Abschätzung (TAB). Mannheim . More