Europeanization of Nation-State Identities? A Franco-German Comparison of Identity Discourses

Project Directors Prof. Dr. Dr. h.c. mult. Beate Kohler-Koch Project Staff Stefan Seidendorf MZES (doctoral program)-funded 2002 – 2005

Research question/goal:

The project aims at identifying a possible "Europeanization" of national identity discourses. It is a well established assumption in political science literature on the democratic future of the EU that legitimate governance "of the people" is difficult to attain because of an underdeveloped notion of European identity.
The project starts from two opposing assumptions, namely (1) that not a "European identity" but "Europeanised national identities" are a sufficient prerequisite for legitimate EU governance and (2) that in a longer time perspective such a Europeanization of national identity is emerging. Research will focus on the empirical evaluation of the national identity discourse and the ways and degrees of their modification in terms of broadening the scope of reference to include “the other”. The expectation is the manifestation of a "Europeanized identity discourse" in "national" colours, integrating to a certain degree a European dimension. Thus, we would be confronted with "French" and "German" European identities, rather than with one European Identity. France and Germany have been chosen as case studies (a) because both countries have been integrated into the European Communities from the very beginning an (b) because they still represent two fairly different national constructions of identity.


Publications

Books

  • Seidendorf, Stefan (2007): Europäisierung nationaler Identitätsdiskurse? Ein Vergleich französischer und deutscher Printmedien. 13, Baden-Baden, Nomos. More
  • Quittkat, Christine (2006): Europäisierung der Interessenvermittlung: Französische Wirtschaftsverbände zwischen Beständigkeit und Wandel. 17, 275. Wiesbaden, Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften. More

Edited Books

  • Schöning, Matthias, Stefan Seidendorf (Eds.) (2006): Reichweiten der Verständigung. Intellektuellendiskurse zwischen Nation und Europa. Heidelberg, Universitätsverlag C. Winter. More

Book Chapters

  • Schöning, Matthias, Stefan Seidendorf (2006): Intellektuellendiskurse zwischen Nation und Europa - Krisenrhetorik und kulturelle Grundlagen. 9-24. Heidelberg, Universitätsverlag C. Winter. More
  • Schöning, Matthias (Eds.) Seidendorf, Stefan (2006): Verständigung gegen die Vergangenheit? - Europäisierung von Erinnerung in Frankreich und Deutschland. 263-289. Heidelberg, Universitätsverlag C. Winter. More

Journal Articles

  • Seidendorf, Stefan (2005): Defining Europe against its Past? Memory Politics and the Sanctions against Austria in France and Germany . German Law Journal, 6, 2, 439-464. More

Presentations

  • Seidendorf, Stefan (2004): Defining Europe against its Past - France, Germany and the Sanctions against Austria. [Workshop der Projektgruppe "The shadows of the Past over the constitutionalization of Europe" (Prof. Joerges), Florenz, 01/07/2004 - 02/07/2004]. More
  • Seidendorf, Stefan (2004): Defining Europe against its Past: France, Germany and the Sanctions against Austria. [ECPR Standing Group on European Studies, 2nd Pan-European Conference: Implications of a wider Europe, Workshop on "Theorizing European Integration", Bologna, 23/06/2004 - 25/06/2004]. More
  • Seidendorf, Stefan (2004): Social and political implications of cultural history and cultural memory - points to debate . [Gemeinsame Tagung des PhD-Programms "European Studies" der Universität Yale und des Nachwuchsprojekts bei der Heidelberger Akademie der Wissenschaften "Europa und das historische Imaginäre. Konstruktion von Vergangenheit als Raum des Politischen", Konstanz, 31/05/2004 - 02/06/2004]. More
  • Seidendorf, Stefan (2004): Zwischenstand des Projekts im Rahmen der Förderung des wissenschaftlichen Nachwuchses durch die Akademie: "Europa und das historische Imaginäre. Konstruktion von Vergangenheit als Raum des Politischen". [Klassensitzung der Heidelberger Akademie der Wissenschaften, Heidelberg, 29/01/2004 - 29/01/2004]. More

Reports

  • Seidendorf, Stefan (2004): Defining Europe against its Past? – Memory Politics and the Sanctions against Austria in France and Germany . More
  • Seidendorf, Stefan (2003): Europeanisation of National Identity Discourses? Comparing French and German Print Media. Edinburgh, ECPR. More
  • Seidendorf, Stefan (2002): Européisation des discours identitaires? – Une comparaison franco-allemande . Paris, Institut d'Études Politiques. More

Thesis

  • Vollmar, Meike (2010): König, Bürgermeister, Bundeskanzler? Politisches Wissen von Grundschülern und die Relevanz familiärer und schulischer Ressourcen. Mannheim, Universität Mannheim. More