Attitudes on Foreign and Security Policy in the U.S. and Germany: A Comparison at the Mass and Elite Level

Project Directors Prof. Dr. Hans Rattinger, Prof. Dr. Harald Schoen Project Staff Jana Pötzschke, Fabian Endres, née Rudnik Agatha Kratz, Dr. Alexander Wuttke, Dr. Matthias Mader DFG-funded 2010 – 2015

Research question/goal:

The project investigated attitudes on foreign and security policy in the United States and Germany. It shed light on how citizens in the U.S. and Germany have responded to the changes in the international system and foreign affairs since 1989/90. In particular, the project addressed the controversial issue if and how the two countries have drifted apart with regard to citizens’ foreign and security policy orientations as a reaction to international events and elite behaviour.

To answer these questions the project acquired and processed 130 relevant surveys conducted between 1974 and 2012. Based on this comprehensive data pool we have carried out secondary data analyses to describe and explain the attitudes on foreign and security policy in a comparative and longitudinal perspective. Two original data sets on German public opinion were collected to address specific theoretical questions impossible to answer with available data. First, the Bamberg Center for Empirical Studies (BACES) conducted 1,162 telephone interviews in October and November, 2010. Second, the project team proposed batteries of foreign and security policy items that were accepted for inclusion in Online Tracking T14 in the framework of the German Longitudinal Election Study (GLES). In this online survey 1,154 interviews were completed in Mai and June, 2011. Both data sets are available through the data archive of GESIS – Leibniz Institute for the Social Sciences.

The analyses reveal transatlantic disagreement over core foreign policy postures, particularly the use of military force. During the whole time period under consideration U.S. citizens were more willing to deploy troops to achieve political ends than German citizens. A somewhat less distinct gap in multilateral postures existed with U.S. citizens showing stronger support for unilateral actions. These core postures were powerful determinants of citizens’ attitudes on both sides of the Atlantic. Differences in elite framing of specific issues led to divergence in the formation of public attitudes towards these policy issues. Furthermore, elite behaviour determined the influence of postures on transatlantic relations.


Publications

Books

  • Mader, Matthias (2017): Öffentliche Meinung zu Auslandseinsätzen der Bundeswehr: Zwischen Antimilitarismus und transatlantischer Orientierung. 262 S.. Wiesbaden, Springer VS. More
  • Rattinger, Hans, Harald Schoen, Fabian Endres, Sebastian Jungkunz, Matthias Mader, Jana Pötzschke (2016): Old Friends in Troubled Waters: Policy Principles, Elites, and U.S.-German Relations at the Citizen Level After the Cold War. 30, 294. Baden-Baden, Nomos. More

Book Chapters

  • Biehl, Heiko, Harald Schoen (Eds.) Mader, Matthias, Rüdiger Fiebig (2015): Determinanten der Bevölkerungseinstellungen zum Afghanistaneinsatz: Prädispositionen, Erfolgswahrnehmungen und die moderierende Wirkung individueller Mediennutzung. 15, 97-121. Wiesbaden, Springer VS. More
  • Biehl, Heiko (Eds.) Pötzschke, Jana, Hans Rattinger, Harald Schoen (2015): Mehr als ein Thema für Spezialisten? Der Afghanistaneinsatz der Bundeswehr und das Wahlverhalten bei der Bundestagswahl 2009. 15, 123-146. Wiesbaden, Springer VS. More
  • Biehl, Heiko (Eds.) Endres, Fabian, Harald Schoen, Hans Rattinger (2015): Außen- und Sicherheitspolitik aus Sicht der Bürger: Theoretische Perspektiven und ein Überblick über den Forschungsstand. 15, 39-65. Wiesbaden, Springer VS. More
  • Biehl, Heiko, Harald Schoen (Eds.) Wagner, Corina, Jana Pötzschke, Hans Rattinger (2015): Eine Bedrohung für die Partnerschaft? Bedrohungswahrnehmungen und Länderimages im deutsch-amerikanischen Verhältnis. 15, 263-291. Wiesbaden, Springer VS. More

Journal Articles

  • Mader, Matthias (2017): Citizens’ Perceptions of Policy Objectives and Support for Military Action: Looking for Prudence in Germany. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 61, 6, 1290-1314. More
  • Endres, Fabian, Matthias Mader, Harald Schoen (2015): On the Relationship Between Strategic Cultures and Support for European Defence: A Comment on Irondelle, Mérand and Foucault. European Journal of Political Research, 54, 4, 848–859. More
  • Endres, Fabian (2014): Die Deutschen und der Euro: Einstellungen zur gemeinsamen Währung in Zeiten der Schuldenkrise. Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft, 8, 2 suppl., 101-121. More
  • Mader, Matthias, Harald Schoen (2013): Alles eine Frage des Blickwinkels? Framing-Effekte und Bevölkerungsurteile über einen möglichen Bundeswehreinsatz in Libyen. Zeitschrift für Internationale Beziehungen, 13, 1, 5-34. More
  • Pötzschke, Jana, Hans Rattinger, Harald Schoen (2012): Persönlichkeit, Wertorientierungen und Einstellungen zu Außen- und Sicherheitspolitik in den Vereinigten Staaten. Politische Psychologie, 2, 4-29. More

Presentations

  • Rudnik, Agatha, Harald Schoen (2014): Mehr als ökonomisches Kalkül? Zu den Bestimmungsfaktoren von auf die Euro-Krise bezogenen Performanz­bewertungen und Policy-Präferenzen. [Tagung Sammelband "Wirtschaftskrise und Wahlverhalten in Deutschland", HWK Delmenhorst, 23/07/2014 - 24/07/2014]. More
  • Mader, Matthias (2013): Coping with External Demands to Participate in Military Interventions - Does German National Identity Mediate International Relations’ Effects on Domestic Attitudes?. [41st ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshops, Johannes Gutenberg Universität, Mainz, 10/03/2013 - 15/03/2013]. More
  • Mader, Matthias (2012): Außen- und sicherheitspolitische Einstellungen in Deutschland, 1981-2007.. [Jubiläumstagung 25 Jahre DVPW-Arbeitskreis „Wahlen und Politische Einstellungen“, Goethe-Universität Frankfurt, 27/06/2012 - 28/06/2012]. More
  • Pötzschke, Jana, Corina Wagner, Hans Rattinger (2012): A Threat to Partnership? Perceived Threat and Attitudes toward German-American Relations. [ISA 2012 Annual Convention, San Diego, 31/03/2012 - 03/04/2012]. More
  • Pötzschke, Jana, Hans Rattinger, Harald Schoen (2011): Personality, Values and Attitudes toward Foreign and Security Policies. [APSA 2011 Annual Meeting, Seattle, 31/08/2011 - 03/09/2011]. More

Thesis

  • Endres, Fabian (2017): Grundüberzeugungen und strategische Kulturen. Struktur und Wirkung außen- und sicherheitspolitischer Grundhaltungen in der deutschen, französischen und britischen Bevölkerung. Mannheim, University of Mannheim. More